Should You Get Rid Of the Old Fence First?
A fence task looks uncomplicated from the road. New timber, new articles, a cool line, done. The component that usually obtains forgotten is the old fence sitting there like a persistent neighbor, and the concern that comes up virtually whenever a person books a quote: must you eliminate the old fence first, or should the fencing contractor manage it as part of the job?
If you ask it delicately, you will obtain a casual response. The truth is extra nuanced. In some scenarios, leaving the existing fence area makes the installer's life easier and conserves you cash. In others, keeping it there just produces extra labour, added time, and a greater possibility of shocks once the articles come out.
I have actually been on site for a lot of secure fencing work throughout various residential properties and conditions, and the decision usually licensed Melbourne fence contractor boils down to one point: what the old fencing is most likely to do throughout the new jobs. Does it obstruct, or does it offer useful reference points? Does it hide the genuine limit circumstance, or does it sit cleanly in the same footprint the brand-new fencing will inhabit? Let's simplify properly.
The genuine question is about accessibility and alignment
When a fence installer (and good fencing contractors) discuss whether the old fencing should appear initially, they are really speaking about two issues:
First, access. Can the staff relocation products, equipment, and auger devices where they require to function? Second, positioning. Is the new fencing mosting likely to make use of the exact same line, or does it need to move somewhat because of boundary clearness, ground conditions, or style changes?
Even a "exact same fencing line" can be various when you measure properly. Lots of old fences were constructed with charitable interpretation of the limit, or in addition to previous fencing footprints. Often the messages are likewise misaligned just sufficient to matter when you are trying to keep panels directly, rails degree, and spacing consistent.

If the existing fencing is still sturdy and in the exact same location, it can imitate a momentary overview. If it is leaning, rotten, or obstructing the dig areas, it becomes friction, and elimination first typically makes one of the most sense.
Why leaving the old fencing can work
There's a practical reason some Fence contractors recommend leaving the old surround location until they prepare to set up. If the old fencing is not falling apart, the staff can use it for reference while they lay out string lines, validate article positions, and plan any changes.
On one property, the old lumber fence was old yet remarkably solid. It was not quite, however it really did not move when you pressed on it. The homeowner considered tearing it out early. The fencing contractor Melbourne team suggested resisting. They took dimensions from the old fence line, confirmed the brand-new layout, and just removed sections as they installed the new blog posts. That method reduced the time the site was open and vulnerable, and the team stayed clear of the "we eliminated whatever, then became aware the boundary line shifts" scenario.
Leaving it in position can additionally lower wind direct exposure if you are near an open location. Momentary securing issues if you are mounting shade towel, washed timber panels, or anything that catches wind during construction.
Another point individuals forget is weather condition. Rainfall adjustments soil uniformity. If the old fence is still there, you can occasionally organize the task in such a way that keeps locations obtainable, as opposed to removing every little thing and transforming the whole site right into a sloppy mess overnight.
Why removing the old fence initially is typically better
Now for the opposite. Eliminating the old fencing early can be the smarter move when the existing fencing is mosting likely to reduce the brand-new set up down, or when it is unsafe in its present form.
I have actually seen scenarios where the old fencing is clearly rotten at the base. The rails and pickets can look "fine" till you begin excavating. Then you pull a board, and the whole area collapses. When that happens mid-install, crews lose time tidying up and resetting. It likewise takes the chance of destructive neighboring landscape design, patio areas, or courses where the particles finishes up.
There's additionally a tidiness and safety and security angle. An installer can function around a fence that is still steady, yet if the old framework is tangled, half-rotten, or loaded with old fasteners, it typically ends up being a threat while you are trying to take care of new products. For a Fence company Melbourne job, that matters since the website requires to remain organized, and the team requires to prevent spending quality time picking splinters out of machinery or untangling old cord that has been stapled in over the years.
If you are placing in a much heavier fencing system, like thicker messages, stonework bases, or specific metal designs, you normally require clear accessibility to dig areas and footing zones. In those cases, elimination initially can decrease the complete work time.
A few "it depends" information that alter the answer
A fencing contract is typically priced around anticipated website problems. The old fencing is among those conditions that can turn the work time. Right here are the aspects that continually affect whether you ought to eliminate it initially, or await the fence contractor to do it.
Post condition and exactly how much the new fence impact will certainly overlap
If the new fence utilizes the exact same article placements, removal might not be essential up until the last moment. If the new articles need to go in other places, or you are changing to deal with alignment, after that the old fence commonly requires to be eliminated early so the crew can dig without battling around old timber.
Boundary confirmation and any kind of study needs
Sometimes the fence line is disputed or unclear. If there's any chance the new fence placement requires to be set off from the old one, the old fence can either assist (as a reference) or perplex (as an inaccurate recommendation). In those situations, a cautious laid out matters greater than rushing removal.
Site access for vehicles, trailers, and augers
If you have slim side accessibility, or a driveway that limits where materials can be organized, the old fence can either create an obstacle or give space to lay lumber briefly. In a lot of suburban yards, the gain access to truths choose what's practical.
Waste handling and avoid bin logistics
Old fencing product needs to go somewhere. Some Fencing installers include elimination and disposal as part of their solution. Others do not, or they charge separately. If you remove it yourself and you have no good disposal strategy, it can develop into a weekend break job that finishes with an avoid container you didn't budget plan for.
I have actually seen homeowners invest an entire day demoing lumber just to discover the bin delivery and regional tipping demands add a price that makes "do it yourself elimination" look less creative on paper. Occasionally it is still worth it, but it must be a calculated choice, not an accidental one.
Whether the old fence is affixed to anything else
A surprisingly common side situation is an old fence that is linked into points like limit keeping walls, celebrity pickets that are connected to old entrance hinges, or areas that function as assistance for vines. Removing it prematurely can produce a cause and effect. Wait for the Fence contractor Melbourne crew to analyze, and they'll commonly handle detaching and restoring cleanly.
When getting rid of initial is usually the much better move
There are clear patterns where removal initially generally helps the task. If your scenario matches numerous of these, it typically makes licensed fencing company sense to eliminate the old fence prior to the installers get here, or a minimum of get rid of the areas that will straight hinder the dig and established out.
- The fencing is noticeably rotten at the base or leaning significantly.
- The old fencing line will certainly relocate, indicating new articles will not land in the very same spots.
- The boards or wire are likely to grab during material handling and digging.
- You have limited accessibility and the staff needs clear room to utilize equipment.
- You are setting up a system that requires clean footing areas, like particular post-and-panel designs or capped tops with particular spacing.
Even in these cases, I still recommend collaborating with your Fencing contractors beforehand. Some installers like to remove their own method so they can manage what obtains harmed, where debris goes, and exactly how the brand-new posts are set without interruption.
When you could maintain the old fence area temporarily
Not every old fence needs to find down initially. In some cases keeping it there until the brand-new work is presented appropriately makes every little thing smoother.
- The existing fencing is steady and straightened closely with the intended new fencing line.
- You wish to preserve personal privacy while the job is scheduled over several days.
- You are not sure regarding limit alignment and desire a reference while measuring.
- The old fence supplies a protected base to momentarily tie string lines or mark positions.
- Removal is likely to damage existing landscaping, paving, or garden features.
In these circumstances, a specialist group often gets rid of just what they have to as they progress, which can maintain your backyard calmer and reduce mess.
The price fact: you might save cash, or you may shed it
People normally ask about eliminating the old fence initially due to cost. That's reasonable. If you tackle the trial yourself, you might decrease the labour line item. Yet fence tasks are not billed just for removal time. They're also billed for the time spent managing access, waste, and the ripple effects of doing points out of sequence.
Here's a grounded way to think of it:
- If the fence crew is already intending to get rid of the old fence, and they can do it quickly as part of the set up operations, your do it yourself demonstration might not save much.
- If the staff will certainly have to function around unstable fencing sections, demolition on your timetable could really decrease their time and improve the outcome.
- If your do it yourself job produces extra damage, you can wind up paying much more for repair services or remediation, specifically around garden beds, courses, or existing articles that weren't expected to be pulled.
The finest "money saving" relocation is not always doing demo yourself. It's making certain the range is clear. Ask your Fence company what removal and disposal includes in the quote, and ask what modifications in price if the old fence is currently gone.
If you are comparing quotes from different Fence contractors, make sure you are comparing the very same extent. One quote could consist of elimination and rubbish disposal, another might presume you handle it. That's where decisions obtain untidy fast.
Safety and legitimacy: the component individuals overlook
Removing a fence seems harmless, however it can include dangers: nails and staples, old cord that reduces, buried timber pieces, unstable blog posts, and anything affixed to the fencing line.
Also, there are border and permit factors to consider. I'm not speaking about significant policies that stop every job. I indicate the sensible side of fence conformity where neighborhood requirements matter. Your installer likely manages this process, yet your obligation increases if you are altering the site prior to authorization checks are complete.
Even if there are no authorizations required for your details job, I still advise you to collaborate. A fencing installer can suggest on exactly how to organize the job without leaving you exposed or developing problems before dimensions and approvals are secured in.
A sensible situation: removing it early versus hosting it
Let me share a common backyard story I have Colorbond fencing company actually seen repeat.
A homeowner desired a brand-new hardwood paling fencing. They got rid of the old panels the day prior to the team showed up. The fence was old steel celebrity pickets with lumber rails, and it was already leaning. Once the boards were off, the pickets were subjected. A couple of were not secure any longer, and when the staff concerned establish string lines, they became aware the old picket placements were not what the house owner assumed.
The installer can still function, but they needed to hang around verifying message placements, dealing with loose residues, and making sure the new holes were safe and not interrupted by the old picket bases. The outcome was still fine, however the timetable slid slightly and the website was dirtier than necessary.
If the property owner had actually coordinated removal with the fencing contractors, they might have eliminated only the sections needed to access the dig zones, while leaving adequate framework in place for positioning checks. In the end, that kind of hosting frequently lowers rework.
So, need to you get rid of the old fencing first?
There isn't a solitary solution that fits every yard. The decision is about timing and range, not just effort.
If your old fence is unpredictable, in the incorrect setting, or clearly in the way of article installment, removing it first can really aid. If the fence is solid and aligned, leaving it till the Fencing Installer Melbourne team is ready to set out and set up can maintain the job safer, cleaner, and even more predictable.
The finest method is a basic preparation discussion. Choose who owns removal in the range, and decide what "done" implies. As an example, does "elimination" indicate drawing boards only, or does it include removing messages and rails, plus disposal?
If you have multiple options, you can additionally ask for an organized strategy. Numerous skilled Fence installers are comfortable eliminating sections in turn, so your personal privacy remains intact and the site remains workable while the work progresses.
Questions to ask your fence contractor prior to you touch a hammer
If you want the choice to be obvious, ask a few targeted questions. This stays clear of the most usual rubbing points.
Here are the concerns I 'd propound your Fence contractor or Fence installer as quickly as the quote conversation begins:
- Does your quote include removing and dealing with the old fencing, including posts and fixings?
- If I eliminate it initially, how does that modification the price and timeline?
- Will the brand-new fence use the same message settings or will certainly you be relocating the line?
- Are there any type of safety or compliance steps I should follow prior to removal?
- Can you organize the job, eliminating just what you require as you install?
With those solutions, the choice ends up being practical rather than guesswork.
What I recommend in actual life
If you are awaiting installment, I generally suggest collaborating initially instead of acting promptly. If the installer states the fencing should boil down for access or safety, you can do the elimination swiftly and maintain the job moving. If the installer states the fencing can stay momentarily for set out and alignment, you'll likely end up with a much better result and less mess.
For many homeowners throughout Melbourne, dealing with well established fencing contractors Melbourne groups likewise implies you get the benefit of experience with neighborhood conditions, dirt kinds, and common yard accessibility. They understand which fencings usually come out easily and which ones become a mid-day of "another thing" once the bolts are exposed.
In other words, the most economical course is not always DIY removal. It's choosing the series that matches your website and your range, so the Fence company work streams efficiently from set out to set up to cleanup.
If you inform me a little bit regarding your current fence (material, problem, and whether you are moving the fence line or replacing in the same Melbourne fence builders impact), I can assist you analyze the likely ideal series for your situation.